My Top 15 Best Legal Dramas TV Series

Carolina

Carolina

Argentinian Carolina has an extensive movie background in the cinematic universe. She is our resident TV analyst and a seasoned expert in global streaming platforms. She showcases her comprehensive knowledge through her love for Netflix 'Originals', Frozen, The Good Place, and The Dragon Prince.

Legal drama has always been a popular genre, somehow derivative and complementing the police procedural TV shows.

In some cases, like the Law & Order franchise, the boundaries between procedural and legal drama are blurred because, depending on the case, some aspects will be stronger.

However, my goal with this article is to focus on pure legal dramas, where lawyers fight in court to solve their cases.

Although it’s a popular genre, the amount of legal dramas is fewer than you can find in the procedural genre.

Let’s take a look at how justice works indoors in the fictional world of TV. Below I’ve put together fifteen of my favourites.

1. Ally McBeal (1997 – 2002)

Comedy, Drama, Fantasy – 5 seasons, 112 episodes

My first choice is perhaps a not-so-conventional legal drama, but it’s definitely one of my favourite shows ever.

Created by David E. Kelley, famous for being the mind behind some of the best legal dramas, Ally McBeal approaches the genre with humour, romance and a bit of fantasy.

Strange mix, uh? Kelley is a former attorney, so he knows how the legal world works and also knows how to take it lightly as well. The series follows the titular character, Ally, a young attorney working for the Boston law firm Cage & Fish.

The firm is co-owned by her law school classmate Richard Fish. The series begins with her first day working there when Ally finds out that her ex-boyfriend Billy is working in the firm too.

Ally is a daydreamer, getting in trouble due to her romantic view of life. She’s far from being a role model, but the key to the show is that she’s a relatable character. At least in the 90s, she was.

Besides the tropes of the legal drama genre, which include court sessions, the series portrays the lives and relationships of the main characters.

The show was the vehicle to fame for several cast members including Calista Flockhart, who played Ally McBeal. She’s followed by Greg Germann (Richard Fish), Gil Bellows (Billy Thomas), Portia de Rossi (Nelle Porter), and Lucy Liu (Ling Woo).

The two veteran members of the cast are Peter MacNicol, who played John Cage, and Courtney Thorne-Smith, who played Georgia Thomas. Robert Downey Jr was among the main cast members during seasons four and five, along with James Marsden (X-MEN) and Hayden Panettiere (Heroes).

Although the series was a hit when it was aired winning several accolades, currently it’s hard to find on streaming. The series is only available on Disney+ in Australia and Canada.

2. The Practice (1997 – 2004)

Crime, Drama, Mystery – 8 seasons – 167 episodes

The Practice was also created and written by David E. Kelley. He worked on The Practice at the same time he was writing Ally McBeal.

All his series are part of a sort of Kelleyverse since they’re all set in the same universe, even sharing crossovers between them. If Ally McBeal relied more on comedy, The Practice was the opposite.

Drama and mystery were recurrent in this show starring Dylan McDermot as Bobby Donnell, a senior lawyer, who is a partner in a Boston law firm. This team of lawyers struggle with the legal ethics related to their profession.

Kelley’s goal was to portray the legal proceeding universe realistically in contrast with other series that fictionalised and romanticised the ups and downs of the profession.

You can find all the seasons of The Practice on Disney+ in Australia and Canada.

3. Damages (2007 – 2012)

Crime, Drama, Mystery – 5 seasons – 59 episodes

Damages is easily among my top 10 TV shows. The mix of a strong cast with complex writing and a high budget since this is a cable network TV show, made Damages a TV show with film quality.

The series revolves around the bond of mentor-protege between two powerful women working at a law firm. The merciless and veteran Patty Hewes, magnifically played by Glenn Close, and the new lawyer Ellen Parsons, played by Australian actress Rose Byrne.

Each season focuses on a large case the firm takes while exploring the complex relationship between Hewes and Parsons.

Both women are surrounded by a strong cast of famous faces throughout the seasons, featuring Tate Donovan, Ted Danson, Noah Bean, Željko Ivanek, Anastasia Griffith, William Hurt, Marcia Gay Harden, Timothy Olyphant, Martin Short, Campbell Scott, John Goodman, Dylan Baker, and Ryan Phillippe.

Originally, Damages was aired on FX, from seasons 1 to 3. Then, due to the high budget, Sony Pictures Television, one of the producing companies, sought a partner network to keep going with the series.

DirectTV was the only showing interest, and seasons 4 and 5 were aired on their Audience Network.

Damages is available for streaming on Hulu in the US and Disney+ in Canada.

4. Murder One (1995 – 1997)

Crime, Drama, Mystery – 2 seasons – 41 episodes

Murder One is one the finest legal dramas you can find. Created by Steven Bochco, Charles H. Eglee, and Channing Gibson, the series was progressive for its time in format and narrative for the legal drama series.

Bochco, who had already created a couple of gems in the procedural genre like NYPD Blue, this time, made his incursion into the purely legal aspect of justice.

The first season follows defence attorney Theodore Hoffman, played by Daniel Benzali, a criminal litigator in his law firm Hoffman and Associates. He’s a genius as a lawyer, mostly focusing on high-profile cases.

What was innovative was the whole season focused on a single major case, with some minor cases in charge of Hoffman’s younger associates.

The case in question was the murder of 15-year-old Jessica Costello. Richard Cross, a charming philanthropist, played by Stanley Tucci, is the first suspect arrested for the crime.

However, Neil Avedon, a young Hollywood star, is later arrested for Costello’s crime and Hoffman becomes his defender. Steven Bochco was known for pushing the boundaries in broadcast TV to offer better quality shows to compete with cable network productions.

His crusade had already begun with NYPD Blue. With Murder One he attempted to follow the format, very common now, that narrates a whole major arc through a season.

In the 90s, this was something new in broadcast TV and it didn’t meet the success Bochco expected. Due to low ratings, the second season of Murder One had a different approach, including a new casting.

Benzali was replaced by Anthony LaPaglia in the role of Jimmy Wyler who is in charge of Hoffman’s law firm. The changes in the cast and narrative style were far from helping the show, which did not recover from the sinking ratings.

At the end of season two, the series was cancelled. Till today, talking about Murder One is basically talking about the first season. Sadly, Murder One is only available on Hulu in Japan.

5. Boston Legal (2004 – 2008)

Comedy, Crime, Drama – 5 seasons – 101 episodes

Boston Legal is another creature by David E. Kelley. The series is a direct spin-off and continuation of The Practice but relies more on comedy than drama.

Boston Legal follows the four main characters from The Practice Season 8: Alan Shore (James Spader), Tara Wilson (Rhona Mitra), Sally Heep (Lake Bell), and Denny Crane (William Shatner) as they work at the offices of Crane, Poole & Schmidt, a high-end law firm based on Boston and focusing both on civil and criminal cases.

The key of the series is on the chemistry between Shore and Crane, who are opposite in their methods and policies, but they’re best friends.

Since the show is lighter than The Practice, humorous situations are common, such as the use of breaking the 4th wall. Boston Legal is available on Hulu in the US and Disney+ in Australia, Canada, and the UK.

6. The Good Wife (2009 – 2016)

Crime, Drama, Mystery – 7 seasons – 156 episodes

The Good Wife is a top-notch legal drama that completed a couple of milestones ahead of its time.

First, as a CBS TV show, it left behind the typical procedural or case of the week to develop serialised plots and subplots, making a complex and rich story.

Second, The Good Wife has a strong female character whose characteristics are rooted in reality. When Robert and Michelle King were in the process of creating the series, their starting point was the role of professional women, in this case, lawyers, when their successful and famous husbands were in the eye of the storm due to a political or sexual scandal.

They noticed that in real life, relevant cases like Hilary Clinton, for example, silently stood next to their husbands during the crisis when the eyes were on them for being the victims of the situation.

The Kings also noticed these women had put a halt to their profession to support their husbands’ careers. With this in mind, they created Alicia Florrick, who has to start working as a lawyer after 13 years of being a stay-at-home mom because her husband Peter, the former Cook County, Illinois State’s Attorney, is in prison after a political corruption and sexual scandal.

Now, Alicia needs to be the provider for her family while dealing with the emotional and social consequences of her husband’s action. Julianna Margulies, an ER alumni, plays Alicia Florrick, a role that earned her a lot of recognition and awards.

The supporting cast is in the hands of famous names such as Alan Cumming, Christine Baranski, and Michael J. Fox.

Richard Vine from The Guardian nailed it in his review of season seven, “This is what long-form TV drama can do so well when it’s in the hands of writers like Michelle and Robert King who really care about their characters (and about drama and, you know, just making entertaining TV)”.

“They convince us that there’s real depth, that Alicia is a character with enough contradictions, emotional range and surprise to bring us back for more than 100 episodes.”

7. Suits (2011 – 2019)

Comedy, Drama – 9 seasons – 134 episodes

Created by Aaron Korsh (Everybody Loves Raymond, Just Shoot Me!) and produced by Universal Content Productions, Suits is a smart legal dramedy which was released on USA Network on June 23, 2011.

The premise is about a college dropout, Mike Ross (Patrick J. Adams), with a photographic memory that allows him to work as a lawyer without attending law school.

Ross is hired by Harvey Specter (Gabriel Macht), a charismatic and successful attorney from a famous firm. He is impressed by Ross’ memory and tries to keep his secret safe.

The series is character-driven, relying on the dynamic between Ross and Specter, the secret they share and a great supporting cast, featuring Rick Hoffman, Meghan Markle (yes the Duchess of Sussex), Gina Torres, and Katherine Heigl.

The success of the series spawned the spin-off Pearson, focusing on Gina Torres’ character Jessica Pearson. When Netflix added Suits to its worldwide catalogue, the series became a success on the streaming platform.

This led Universal Content Productions to produce a spin-off called Suits: L.A. with Korsh as showrunner.

Suits also has South Korean and Japanese remakes produced in 2018, airing on KBS2 and Fuji TV, respectively. Besides being available on Netflix worldwide, Suits can be found on BBC iPlayer in the UK and Peacock TV in the US.

8. How To Get Away With Murder (2014 – 2020)

Crime, Drama, Mystery – 6 seasons – 90 episodes

How to Get Away with Murder was created by Peter Nowalk and produced by Shonda Rhimes (Grey’s Anatomy).

The premise focuses on Annalise Keating, played by Viola Davis, a defence attorney who teaches law at a prestigious university in Philadelphia. Keating chooses five of her first-year students to work as interns in her law firm.

They, soon, will see themselves trapped in a murder plot. I’m not going to go deep in detail because it’s a series easy to spoil.

Viola Davis’ performance has been praised by critics and audiences alike, earning her several accolades. Famke Janssen (X-MEN) became recurring in season two, playing defence attorney Eve Rothlo, receiving critical acclaim for her acting.

Currently, How to Get Away with Murder is available worldwide on Netflix.

9. Judging Amy (1999 – 2005)

Drama – 6 seasons – 138 episodes

Created by Amy Brenneman, who also played the titular character, Judging Amy is based on the experiences of Brenneman’s mother.

The series follows Amy Gray, an attorney who after her divorce, moves to Hartford, her hometown, with her six-year-old daughter Lauren to live with her widowed mother, Maxine Gray, played by Tyne Daly.

Returning to her hometown means for Amy to get back to her roots both in family and friendships, with all the advantages and challenges that pose that situation.

Although the legal cases are the motif of the series, the core of the story is Amy and her relationship with her mother. Sadly, Judging Amy is hard to find on streaming, it’s only available on Pluto TV in Canada.

10. Shark (2006 – 2008)

Crime, Drama, Mystery – 2 seasons – 38 episodes

Starring James Woods, Shark is a legal drama that follows Sebastian Stark, a famous Los Angeles defence attorney who after winning the defence of a wife-abuser, the guy ends up killing his wife.

Stark tries to cope with the situation, dealing with the guilt of the unorthodox methods he applies in his profession. While going through this process, he’s invited to become a public prosecutor so he can use his talent to send the guilty people to prison instead of setting them free.

The series also deals with Stark’s relationship with his team and daughter as he adapts to his new role of prosecutor.

11. Daredevil (2015 – 2018)

Action, Crime, Drama – 3 seasons – 39 episodes

You may be wondering why a Marvel superhero is on the legal drama list. Well, Matt Murdock, Daredevil’s civil identity, is a lawyer by day, dealing with all the ups and downs of justice in court. By night, he puts on his superhero suit and seeks justice by other means.

Oh, did I mention he’s blind and uses his highly-trained senses to fight? Yes, it’s not your average legal drama, but it’s one of the coolest.

This series, which today is still regarded as a masterpiece as a comic book character adaptation, was spawned as one of the creatures from the Netflix-Disney partnership.

Yes, there was a time when they didn’t hate each other and produced great series together until one day Disney snapped and wanted to buy Netflix, but Netflix said nope.

Big corps gossip aside, Daredevil is a great series balancing the typical tropes of any legal drama with superhero action. This was the first TV show to be officially part of the MCU.

What does this mean? Daredevil is part of the continuity of the Marvel Studio films. The show was produced by Marvel Television in association with ABC Studios and Netflix.

The story follows Matt Murdock as he balances his life with his public persona as an attorney and his secret identity as Daredevil, a justice fighter. From his two identities, he uncovers a conspiracy in the criminal world in the hands of Wilson Fisk.

Matt Murdock is played by English actor Charlie Cox, who has been praised for his performance. Daredevil proved to be great viewing beyond the superhero frenzy and has caught the attention of people who aren’t familiarised with the Marvel universe. You can find all the episodes of Daredevil on Disney+ worldwide.

12. She-Hulk: Attorney at Law (2023)

Action, Adventure, Comedy – 1 season – 9 episodes

You’re probably thinking I’ve lost my mind in putting another Marvel series on this list. It’s not my fault that Marvel loves making superheroes out of tormented attorneys. She-Hulk received so much hate from people who hate anything with a woman in a leading role.

People that never in their lives read She-Hulk comics, so they don’t understand that the humour and the antics are in the source.

People who accept absurd humour in Deadpool (don’t get me wrong, I love Deadpool, I’m just pissed off by double standards), but if the same kind of humour comes from a female character it’s considered gross.

Well, I think you get my point. The thing is, She-Hulk is a great show with a high dose of comedy, and legal drama tropes, and in the middle of chaos, it addresses some serious topics that women face daily like sextortion.

The series follows the adventures of Jennifer Walters as an attorney and as She-Hulk. Yes, she belongs to Bruce Banner’s family, in fact, she’s his cousin.

Although Walters’ transformation is less troublesome than Banner’s, she has to deal with her double identity and fame. If you don’t care about what haters say on social media, give She-Hulk a try.

The show is available on Disney+ worldwide.

13. Partner Track (2022)

Drama – 1 season – 10 episodes

This Netflix original series is based on the novel by Helen Wan, The Partner Track. The story follows Ingrid Yun, played by Arden Cho, a young lawyer whose goal is to be a partner at an elite New York law firm.

Of course, the ride won’t be easy as the law world is about cruel competition, and it’s difficult if you’re a woman and worse if you’re a woman of colour. After one season, the series was cancelled, Netflix’s vicious hobby.

However, it’s worth watching. I’ve read some reviews accusing it of being formulaic and with cliches. Sorry, but not everything could be dead serious like The Practice. Partner Track is good entertainment inside a genre that has been formulaic for ages.

14. The Lincoln Lawyer (2022 – Present)

Crime, Drama, Mystery – 3 seasons – 25 episodes

David E. Kelley is back with this adaptation of Michael Connelly’s books. The Lincoln Lawyer is a Netflix original series starring Manuel Garcia-Rulfo (Goliath) in the role of Mickey Haller, a criminal defence lawyer who solves cases in the backseat of his Lincoln Navigator in Los Angeles.

In the meantime, he deals with recovering from his drug addiction.

The supporting cast features Neve Campbell as Maggie McPherson, a criminal prosecutor and Mickey’s first ex-wife, Becki Newton as Lorna Crane, Mickey’s second ex-wife, and Jazz Raycole as Izzy Letts, who works as Mickey’s driver to pay her legal fees to him.

The series is available on Netflix worldwide.

15. Your Honor (2020 – 2023)

Crime, Drama, Suspense – 2 seasons – 20 episodes

If you’re looking for a thriller within the legal drama genre, then Your Honor is your choice. The series, starring Bryan Cranston, is an American adaptation of the Israeli TV show Kvodo.

Originally it started as a miniseries, but due to the success, Showtime renewed it for a second season. Cranston put on the shoes of Judge Michael Desiato, who has gained the respect in New Orleans for his job.

However, his life turns upside-down when his teenage son, Adam, is involved in a hit-and-run traffic accident killing another teenager. In the beginning, Michael follows his righteous morals as a judge and encourages his son to surrender to justice.

However, he changes his mind when he finds out that the boy his son accidentally killed is the son of a big crime lord related to the mafia.

In order to protect his son, Michael starts a network of lies with dangerous and tragic consequences. You can find Your Honor on Prime Video in the US, Paramount+ in Latin America and, Stan in Australia.

Summary

Legal drama (and comedy) is a genre not so prolific as the procedural one but spawned many titles through the years.

In this list, I intend to provide a selection of legal dramas that have been popular due to their success both with critics and audiences.

If you’re a fan of court sessions and enjoy seeing how attorneys and prosecutors enter into a war with each other, be sure to check these series. If you’re new to the genre, here you have a curated list to begin.

Let me know which legal drama is your favourite by dropping some lines in the message box below.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts